gold star for USAHOF

Known as “Chief” due to his Algonquin heritage, George Armstrong would become the most tenured Toronto Maple Leaf of all time, participating in 1,188 Games.

Armstrong first appeared in a Leafs uniform in the 1949-50 Season, and was a stalwart at Right Wing two years later.  While he was not a gifted skater, he had a high hockey IQ, expert positioning and rarely lost a grind in the corner.  

Armstrong was not a potent scorer but was the most consistent player for a 15-year period.  His career-high in Points was only 53 (1961-62), but he cracked the 40-Point mark seven times, and he was very good on the defensive side of the ice.  Armstrong became the team captain in 1957 and held that post for twelve seasons, overseeing four Stanley Cups, arguably making him the most successful Maple Leaf to don the "C."

Retiring after the 1970-71 Season, Armstrong scored 726 Points and remains one of the most respected players in franchise history. 

Armstrong was chosen for the Hockey Hall of Fame in 1975, and the Leafs hung his likeness to the rafters of the Air Canada Center in 1998.  His number 10 (along with Syl Apps) was retired in 2016.

George Armstrong

With all due respect to George Armstrong, the Hockey Hall of Fame may not be the right place for him. It was not that Armstrong wasn’t a good player; he was a multi time All Star game participant who spend his long career as a member of the Toronto Maple Leafs who won four Stanley Cups. Although he played in multiple All Star Games, the Right Winger never had more than 25 goals or 55 points in a season and was never considered by his peers to be an elite player. George Armstrong was however considered a great leader and was the Leafs Captain for many years and was also considered a very intelligent player who knew how to make the best of his ability, and had some of his performances in the playoffs. Frankly, we are on the fence on this one.