Because of the sheer greatness of Dominik Hasek, Ryan Miller was never going to be the best Goalie in Sabres history. That being said, we know that Miller was pretty damned good.
Miller joined the Sabres organization after three years at Michigan State, and in his fourth year of professional hockey, Miller became the primary netminder for Buffalo. He kept his GAA well under three, and finished sixth in Vezina voting in 2006-07, but Miller would have a banner year in 2009-10. That season, Miller led the NHL in Point Shares (16.8), winning the Vezina and was fourth in Hart Trophy voting. Miller would also post career-highs in Wins (41), GAA (2.22) and Save Percentage (.929). On top of everything, Miller was the prime Goalie for the United States in the Olympics, and while the Americans fell to Canada in the Gold Medal Game, it was widely believed that Miller was the best player of the tournament.
Miller could not match that year, but he remained a strong Goalie, later playing for St. Louis, Vancouver and Anaheim, finishing an 18-year career in 2021. He played in 540 Games, and had a 284-186-57 Record with a 2.58 GAA.
With the phenomenal nickname of "Z-Bo," Zach Randolph played one year at Michigan State before declaring for the NBA Draft. It was the Portland Trail Blazers who would take him 19th overall, and he became the starting Power Forward two years later. That season, Randolph won the Most Improved Player of the Year Award and had his first 20/10 year. He would accomplish the 20/10 feat again in 2006-07.
Born (and died) in the most football like city on this Planet Earth (Canton, Ohio), George Saimes would sign with the Buffalo Bills in 1963 after playing collegiately at Michigan State.
Drafted 3rd Overall in 1984 from Michigan State, the New York Giants would have a longtime fixture in their Linebacking corps in Carl Banks. Banks was an All-Rookie Selection, and he would later be named to the Pro Bowl and was a First Team All-Pro in 1987, the year after he was a large part of their Super Bowl XXI win. Banks would again hoist the Lombardi Trophy high four years later in Super Bowl XXV.