Apologies, gang, as this should have been done months ago.
We have updated our Notinhalloffame.com Rock list to include those for the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. This list goes up to 600, and you can find the entire list here.
For reference, the current top ten are:
#1. The Smiths. Eligible since 2009.
#2. Jethro Tull. Eligible since 1994.
#3. Oasis. Eligible since 2020.
#4. Pixies. Eligible since 2015.
#5. New Order. Eligible since 2007.
#6. The White Stripes. Eligible since 2023.
#7. Iron Maiden. Eligible since 2005.
#8. Gram Parsons. Eligible since 1993.
#9. King Crimson. Eligible since 1995.
#10. Coldplay. Eligible since 2023.
We will continue our lists often. Thank you for your support.
The “Hall of Fame Season” has come to an end with the announcement of Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Class, and it is the largest class in recent memory.
The Cleveland based institution elected Missy Elliott, Willie Nelson, Sheryl Crow, Rage Against the Machine, Kate Bush, George Michael and The Spinners. Chaka Khan, Al Kooper and Bernie Taupin enter via the Musical Excellence Award. Link Wray and DJ Kool Herc will receive the Musical Influence Award and Don Cornelius will get the Ahmet Ertegun Award.
Four of the elected members, Elliott, Nelson, Crow and Michael enter on their first appearance on the ballot. Missy Elliott becomes the first female rapper inducted, and Nelson capped off an incredible week, first by turning 90 and now with this induction, though unlike Elliott, who only became eligible, has been eligible for decades. George Michael won the fan vote, continuing the trend of fan vote winners entering the Hall.
RATM enters on their fourth attempt, and their induction should help other Alternative acts from the 1990s. The Spinners also enter on their fourth try, and have been eligible since 1986. Kate Bush, who has been enjoying a renaissance was also nominated twice before.
Failing to gain entry were A Tribe Called Quest, Cyndi Lauper, New Order/Joy Division, Iron Maiden, White Stripes, Soundgarden and Warren Zevon.
We will begin work on revising our Notinhalloffame Rock List for next year.
We here at Notinhalloffame.com would like to congratulate the impending members of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame has put forth one of the most diverse group of nominees for the Class of 2023, and let’s get right into who they have nominated:
A Tribe Called Quest is nominated for the first time, and should the Alternative Hip-Hop group get in, it would open the doors for many of their ilk.
Cyndi Lauper receives her first nomination since being eligible in 2009. With a barrage of 80s hits, and an activist legacy that plays well to the voter base, this is a great ballot for her, as only Kate Bush falls close to her category.
Iron Maiden collects a second nomination, but the Heavy Metal gods face an uphill climb as the voters have shown that they do not care for their genre.
Joy Division/New Order are in for a combined nomination, which greatly improves the chances for all parties in question. This is not unprecedented, as the Hall previous nominated and inducted, as the Small Faces and Faces were put forth together. Neither group has been nominated before, and this first nomination could be their only one as this is a very strong candidate.
Kate Bush earned her fourth nomination, and no artist has enjoyed more of an interest in her music over the past twelve months with her song, “Running Up That Hill” featured on Stranger Things. Cyndi’s appearance on this ballot, could delay Bush one more time.
George Michael receives his first nomination after being eligible since 2010. The mastermind behind Wham!, had a monstrous solo career generating five number ones as a solo, and two more as a duet (one with Aretha Franklin and one with Elton John). This would be a posthumous induction, as Michael passed away on Christmas Day, 2016 from heart disease.
Missy Elliot is nominated in her first year on the ballot, and should she get in, she will be the first female rapper inducted. Generally, we try not to equate everything to gender, but the above fact makes her a near-lock for induction, but we have had similar thoughts before.
Rage Against the Machine received a fifth nomination, and now fifth in the last six years. Will RATM get in this year, or does Soundgarden siphon off some of their votes?
Sheryl Crow is also a first-time nominee. Eligible since 2019, Crow was very successful in the 1990s with many hits, but she may not have the influence factor to get over some of the other artists here.
Soundgarden is now a two-time nominee, the first coming in 2020. The Seattle group could cancel out RATM, and arguably this is a bad ballot for both.
The Spinners return with another nomination, their fourth overall and first since 2016. Could the Philly Soul pioneers play spoiler?
Warren Zevon is nominated for the first time after being eligible since 1995, and it a long time coming for the acclaimed Singer/Songwriter. We have seen before how the voting body reacts to a first-time nominee who has eligible for 20 years, but he is not the only one with that credential here.
The White Stripes are in the same camp as Missy Elliot, as they are nominated on their first year. This is the type of group that the Hall drools over; successful, influential, a tad eccentric and polotically in tune with their ideals.
Willie Nelson finally got his first nomination after decades of eligibility, and following Dolly Parton last year, does this not feel like Willie is getting in?
The Class will be announced on a date yet to be determined.
We would like to congratulate the 2023 nominees for making it to this step.
Simmons has been critical about the Hall before, first regarding the long wait that his band endured, and then when they did get in, that they only inducted the original four members. RATM member, Tom Morello, was KISS’s inductor, and is a member of the Rock Hall committee, who pushed hard for KISS’s induction.Sadly, Rage Against The Machine shut out of RR Hall of Fame. The Hall should be ashamed of themselves….
— Gene Simmons (@genesimmons) May 13, 2021
When you follow halls of fame as diligent as we do, it is a festive season when you have the Baseball Hall of Fame and Football Hall of Fame announce their classes a week about. Throw in the fact that the Rock and Roll Hall is now announcing their Finalists, we have an unprecedented time on our hands.
Due to COVID-19, the nomination process for the Class of 2021 was delayed by several months, but until two days ago there was no set date as to when it we learn who would be on the ballot.
The nominees are:
Carole King: Ranked #87 on Notinhalloffame.com. King entered the Rock Hall a long time ago as a songwriter with her partner, Gerry Goffin, but her solo work as a performer is also Hall worthy. This is the first time she has been nominated since 1989.
Chaka Khan: Ranked #168 on Notinhalloffame.com. The Hall wants Chaka Khan in, as they have nominated her in the past as a solo, and later with the group, Rufus. Again, as a solo, this is her sixth overall nomination.
Devo: Ranked #80 on Notinhalloffame.com. Devo returns to the ballot after a year, and their work in Post-Punk/New Wave is among the most influential of its day.
Dionne Warwick: Ranked #362 on Notinhalloffame.com. Warwick has a trophy case full of Grammys and a laundry list of hits, but with an Adult Contemporary sound, her rock and roll credibility is suspect. That hasn’t stopped Hall voters before.
Fela Kuti: Ranked #397 on Notinhalloffame.com. Every year there is a wild card, and this is year it is Fela Kuti, the most important singer from Africa. If the Rock Hall voters value world music, he is the best choice they could make.
Foo Fighters: Ranked #3 on Notinhalloffame.com. Foo Fighters are in their first year of eligibility and it should be no surprise to anyone that they were nominated, nor should anyone be shocked to see them gain immediate entry. An induction will make Dave Grohl a two-time inductee, having already been enshrined with Nirvana.
The Go-Go’s: Ranked #111 on Notinhalloffame.com. The Go-Go’s were he first all-female band to go #1 on Billboard, and this is their first nomination since being eligible in 2006.
Iron Maiden: Ranked #13 on Notinhalloffame.com. This is a pleasant surprise as the Heavy Metal gods have never been nominated despite being eligible since the 2004 vote. Heavy Metal has struggled to find representation in the Rock Hall, and in the past few years, Judas Priest and Motorhead have been on the ballot, but failed to gain entry. It might be a hard call to see Iron Maiden achieving what the others did not.
Jay-Z: Ranked #2 on Notinhalloffame.com. Jay-Z is one of the most important, if not THE most important hip-hop artist in the last thirty years. If you don’t agree with that assessment, you can’t deny that he is among the most successful. Like Foo Fighters, Jay-Z is on their first year of eligibility and he should get in.
Kate Bush: Ranked #132 on Notinhalloffame.com. Bush’s unique singing voice was only matched by her unique material. She was nominated before in 2018.
LL Cool J: Ranked #100 on Notinhalloffame.com. LL Cool J is nominated for the fifth time, but he again he is not the biggest named Hip Hop artist on the ballot. The nomination of Jay-Z hurts LL Cool J more than anyone else, but there is no reason that two Hip Hop stars can’t get inducted in the same year.
Mary J. Blige: Ranked #252 on Notinhalloffame.com. Blige earns her first nomination on her third year of eligibility. Her diverse catalogue earns her a spot, but with other more established African-American women on this ballot, this will be a tough one for her to get elected on.
The New York Dolls: Ranked #89 on Notinhalloffame.com. The New York Dolls are this year’s proto-punk/punk nominee and the David Johansen led group were nominated once before, back in 2001.
Rage Against the Machine: Ranked #40 on Notinhalloffame.com. RATM is on their third ballot, and finding a group that fused rap and hard rock/metal better than them is a daunting task.
Tina Turner: Ranked #113 on Notinhalloffame.com. Tina Turner was long ago inducted as one half of Ike & Tina, but Tina’s solo career far eclipsed the duo in popularity. This is the first time that Tina has been nominated as a solo, and should she get in, she joins Stevie Nicks as female double-inductee.
Todd Rundgren: Ranked #12 on Notinhalloffame.com. Rundgren’s overall body of work as a performer, songwriter and producer puts many Rock and Roll Hall of Famers to shame. Eligible since 1996, Rundgren had to wait until 2018 for his first nomination, and he was also on the ballot last year.
We know there will be copious amounts of rage regarding who was not nominated. There always is. We do feel that the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame nominating committee did a good job nominating musicians across a musical landscape, and have for the last seven years.
This ballot also has the greatest number of women in nominating history.
What happens next is up to the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame voters.
Congratulations to all the Finalists, and let the debate again.
We love this.
Another significant figure who is not in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame has stated his contempt towards that institution.
That man is Iron Maiden frontman, Bruce Dickinson who in a spoken word tour in Australia had this to say when asked by a fan if he thought that Iron Maiden should be in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. He had this to say:
“Absolutely. I actually think the Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame is an utter and complete load of bollocks, to be honest with you. It’s run by a bunch of sanctimonious bloody Americans who wouldn’t know rock and roll if it hit them in the face. They need to stop taking Prozac and start drinking fucking beer."
That sounds pretty rock and roll to us!
The heavy metal band has been eligible for the Hall since 2004 and has never been nominated.
Iron Maiden is ranked #14 by us on Notinhalloffame on or list of those to consider for the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
As always we can’t get enough of the drama!
The first content that we ever put up on Notinhalloffame.com was our original Rock and Roll list ranking those who were not yet in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame but were worthy of consideration. It ranked 100 acts, and as we continued on we extended it to 500. Our eventual intent is to get to 1,000 and at present we now have 567 ranked.
The selection of The Moody Blues, The Cars, Nina Simone, Bon Jovi and Dire Straits to the Hall means that they are removed and newly eligible acts now populate our list. Rankings of existing musicians have been altered based on your comments and votes.
The new top 25 features:
Radiohead takes over the top spot after being ranked #2. They were nominated last year in their first year of eligibility and it was widely speculated that they would get in but it should be only a matter of time.
Kraftwerk returns to the number two rank after being #1 last year. The influential band has been nominated four times (2003, 2013, 2015 & 2017) and was our original number one selection when we put out our first list in 2010.
Jethro Tull holds firm at #3. To the surprise of many, the British Progressive Rock band has never been nominated for the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame despite being eligible for twenty-five years.
The Smiths also held their spot at #4. This is the third year that they have been ranked this high and they were nominated in 2015 and 2016.
Roxy Music is ranked #5 for the second year in a row. They have been eligible for the Hall since 1997.
MC5 is ranked #6 for the third straight year. They have been nominated the last two years.
Gram Parsons moves up one spot to #7, which is his highest ranking to date. He was nominated three times in 2002. 2004 & 2005.
Willie Nelson drops down to #8. Nelson has never been nominated.
New Order returns to the top 10 moving from up from #11. They also have never been nominated and have been ranked as high as #5.
Judas Priest makes their first appearance in our top ten taking the #10 position after being ranked #13. The heavy metal pioneers also earned their first nomination last year after being eligible since 1999.
The Cure moves up to #11 from #14, which is their highest rank to date. They were nominated in 2012.
John Coltrane remains at #12. He has never been nominated.
Todd Rundgren continues to climb our rank, moving from #15 to #13. He has moved up every year since our list’s inception and he has also never been nominated although has been eligible since 1995.
Iron Maiden climbs to #14 after being #17. They have also never been nominated and this to date their highest rank.
Dick Dale moved up one spot to #15. The “King of the Surf Guitar” has never been nominated.
T.Rex rises two spots to #16, their highest rank to date. They have also never been nominated.
Pixies also went up two spots to #17. Never nominated, they have been eligible for the Hall since 2012.
Janet Jackson also increased her rank and is now at the #18 hole. Jackson was nominated in both 2016 & 2017.
Joy Division reached the top 20 for the first time reaching #19. Like New Order, they have never been nominated.
King Crimson returns to the top 20. They were ranked #23 last year and they have never been nominated.
Wu-Tang Clan plummeted from #10 to #21. They have only been eligible for two years.
Depeche Mode continued to rise and are now #22. They have been nominated for the last two years.
Big Star dropped to #23. This is their lowest ranking to date and they have yet to be nominated.
Link Wray moved up three to #24, his first time in our Top 25. The guitar legend was nominated last year and also in 2014.
Beck closes the Top 25. He was ranked at that last year.
As you see, no new act made our revised Top 25. That doesn’t mean that there are not new entries as we have 19 debuts to our Notinhalloffame.com list.
They are:
Bjork at #56.
Dave Matthews Band at #81.
Blink-182 at #90.
Rancid at #100.
Bone Thugs-N-Harmony at #128.
Snoop Dogg at #178.
The Roots at #235.
Built to Spill at #249.
Shania Twain at #255.
Sheryl Crow at #304.
Counting Crows at #309.
Toni Braxton at #320.
Everclear at #381.
AFI at #387.
Collective Soul at #400.
Aimee Mann at #420.
Frank Black at #454.
Elastica at #484.
As always, we here at Notinhalloffame.com thank you for your votes and comments and encourage you to offer more as this does alter future rankings.
Look for our revised Notinhalloffame.com Baseball list in the upcoming weeks.
Heavy Metal is one of those genres that will generate more passion from its listeners than most. Recent inductee, Metallica suffered a minor backlash for cutting their hair and softening their sound in the 90’s to become more commercially viable. Yet as successful as Metallica was, they may not be the Heavy Metal band with the most die hard fans. Iron Maiden might just have that honorary title.