The best season of Dave May’s career occurred in 1973 when he would make the All-Star Team and finish 8th in MVP voting. That year, May would have 25 Home Runs with 189 Hits, a .303 Batting Average and would also lead the American League in Total Bases and Win Probability Added. While Dave May would never have a season like that again, he would have another two decent campaigns with Milwaukee. Over May's two runs in Milwaukee, he would have 652 Hits.