Baseball’s forgotten heroes who deserve a spot in Cooperstown

In 2024, three players were inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame by the Baseball Writers of Association of America (BBWAA). They were 3rd baseman Adrian Beltré, 1st baseman Todd Helton, and catcher Joe Mauer. 

The 2025 Baseball Hall of Fame ballots are in, and the new inductees will be announced on January 21st. There were 28 candidates on the ballot this year, with 14 of those on the ballot for the first time. The other 14 had been on the ballot in 2024. For some, this is their final ballot before becoming ineligible for nomination.

Players need to have 75% to meet the threshold for induction into the Hall of Fame. Not every player has the same journey toward making it into the Hall of Fame. For example, on the 2025 ballot, we have Billy Wagner and Ichiro Suzuki. Wagner is on his 10th and final ballot and has crawled his way towards 75%, having only received 10.5% on his first ballot. Suzuki, on the other hand, is likely to be a unanimous vote for the Hall of Fame (only the second in history) on his very first ballot.

The odds on Ichiro Suzuki making it into the Hall of Fame are very good. For many other players, it’s much harder to tell how the voting has gone. Betting on who is making it into the Hall of Fame has become a niche market for baseball fans. Betting on baseball has always been hugely popular and occasionally very controversial.

The easiest way to bet on baseball markets is to use an online sportsbook, and finding sports iGaming apps is now easier than ever. Online sports betting has been steadily gaining ground in the United States since the Supreme Court overruled the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA) in 2018. Since then, each state has had the power to determine its own sports betting laws, and most have chosen to legalize sports betting online, in person, or both.

While not everyone thinks people should be able to bet on things outside the games, like drafts, inductions, college games, and signings, most baseball fans are comfortable with betting on the MLB. No matter how you feel about the topic, it is interesting to consider which players have made it into the National Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown and which ones have been overlooked.

Today, we’re going to talk about some of baseball’s forgotten heroes who deserve a spot in Cooperstown. Some were overlooked from the start and never made it onto the ballots, others made it through the voting process but never seemed to have enough sway to get above that 75% threshold. While it may technically be too late for these players to make it in, there’s always a chance that the Hall of Fame could consider these special circumstances and bend the rules just a little bit.

Alex Rodriguez

Shortstop Alex Rodriguez is a player that many thought would make it into the Hall of Fame in his first eligible year. Instead, he only received 34.8% of the vote. This likely has nothing to do with his record as a player and more to do with his very public transgressions and his use of performance-enhancing drugs during part of his career. 

“A-Rod” spent the first years of his career with the Seattle Mariners (1994–2000), before moving to the Texas Rangers for a brief stint (2001–2003). He is best remembered for his time spent playing for the New York Yankees (2004–2013, 2015–2016). He is considered one of the greatest players of all time, and that is shown through the records he has broken and the consistent awards he has won. This includes being named to the All-Star team 14 times, 3x AL MVP, 2x Gold Glove, 10x Silver Slugger, and many more. 

Unfortunately, Rodriquez also used performance-enhancing drugs during his time with the Texas Rangers. While this does cast a shadow on his successes, Rodriguez still deserves to be in the Hall of Fame because of his sheer talent.

Barry Bonds 

Barry Bonds falls into a similar category as Rodriguez. He is one of the greatest players in the history of the sport but his legacy is tainted by his steroid usage. The left fielder played for the Pittsburgh Pirates (1986–1992) and the San Francisco Giants (1993–2007). He was an all-around great player who made his presence felt no matter where he was. 

Bonds still holds many of the MLB’s hitting records. These include most career home runs (762), most single season home runs (73), most walks, and most intentional walks in basically every category. On the other hand, he was one of the central players in the MLB steroid scandal. 

Bonds’ eligibility for the Hall of Fame has passed. He is one player who should be considered under special circumstances in recognition of all that he did for the sport.

Johan Santana

The case of John Santana is a frustrating one. He came to the MLB late after languishing with various minor league teams for years. When he finally made it to the major league with the Minnesota Twins, he showed that he was one of the best starting pitchers in the game. After several seasons with the Twins, he was traded to the New York Mets (2008–2010, 2013) where he continued to display a huge amount of talent. He is one of the only pitchers to have pitched a solo no-hitter.

Unfortunately, he was injury-prone. He was injured for three consecutive seasons of his career. This severely limited the amount of time he could play and ultimately destroyed his chances of making it to the Hall of Fame. 

If it’s any consolation for Santana and his many fans, his talents on the mound have been recognized in his home country of Venezuela. In 2022, he was inducted into the Venezuelan Baseball Hall of Fame with 81% of the vote.